Well the biggest show down in trail running is about to happen, Meltzer, Jurek and Koerner are representing the USA vs. those crafty Europeans. We do not know much about the top Europeans except it’s their home course and we are there to steal the show. Karl e-mailed me and said the course is awesome and the media is out of control. Karl sounds all calm and is ready to go do what he does, climb some rugged terrine. Every time Karl goes through an aid station I will receive an e-mail with in a minute, I will then post the updates as I receive them. Race starts 10:30 am today!
3:42 update: La Balme check point
USA runners hold 3 of the top 4 positions so far lead by Jurek, Koerner then Meltzer all on the exact same pace!! First place is held by Mermoud who is 10 minutes ahead of the team USA, but will he last ? It’s early but could we see the USA take top 3 ?
4:06 update: Bonhom check point
Mermoud holds first place buy 13 minutes over Meltzer who is only one minute in front of Jurek and Koerner. Hold on for a barn burner !! Wahsatchspeedgoat must be feeling good!! Two scrapes~ Karl went from 6th to 2nd place so far.
4:21 update: Chap check point
Mermoud opens lead over Meltzer by 15 minutes, this guy is digging early. Jurek and Koerner are just a couple minutes behind. race time 05h37mn24s
Go NIKKI! First woman by a humongous margin, 41st overall as of 3:45 pm rocky mountain time!
6:45 update: Seigne
Mermoun leads Meltzer by 11 minutes, Karl managed to close the gap by 4 minutes with a long way to go. Koerner is 7 minutes behind Karl and Jurek is lerking back just 10 minutes. Nicki has a nice lead for the women!! oh boy! 07h13mn27s
8:12 update: Courm check point
Mermoud is looking strong, he has a 13 minute lead ahead of Delebarre and a 17 minute lead over Olmo and Meltzer. The Euros are making a move.
8:40 update: USA update
Meltzer 4th place 18 minutes behind the leader
Koerner 9th place 24 minutes behind the leader
Jurek 14th place 31 minutes behind the leader
Karnazes 124th place ??? minutes behind the leader
Nikki 36th place, yea go get a victory for the USA women!!
9:22 update: Bertone check point
We are about half way~first four runner in~
Mermoud 1st
Delebarre 14 minutes behind
Olmo 14 minutes behind
Meltzer 20 minutes behind – leading USA – 10h42mn03s – 81.80 km
Nikki Kimball – still kicking it up!
12:19 update:Col Ferret
After the big climb Meltzer (13h21mn19s) climbs into second place just 11 minutes behind Mermoun. Looks like Meltzer is in a battle of his life with the Euros ! Go Karl hang tough hopefully he didn’t spend to much energy on the big climb, not! Check it out Dean has put on a push to pass Jurek and Koerner !! Daylight is back and it’d time to scrape hard Karl!
Nikki is still in 34th place overall for the top women!!
12:54 update: Fouly check point
There is a long downhill after Ferret, Meltzer closed the gap to 5 minutes behind Mermoun. This must be a technical downhill where Karl’s hooves are good and sharpened, WSG is feeling good and dancing to his favorite tunes ! He is digging deep and smells a top 5 finish or better?
7:45 a.m. USA update: Looks like the Euros took over during our night.
Meltzer 12th place
Nikki 24th place
Dean 73rd place
Koerner 1375th place
Juek 1377th place
1st Olmo almost to the finish
2nd Mermoud
3rd Lukas
nice job, these guys are finishing strong!
OLMO WINS 2007 CHAMPION, GREAT RUN !!
Nickki Kimball finished for the top women super congrats!! 19th overall!
Dean is on his way to a top 50 finish? Way to go Dean!!! on boy !

84 thoughts on “du Mont-Blanc USA vs. Europeans”
It was great to get Hal’s report and I am obviously interested in the cultural side of the whole thing. Clearly, it is a beautiful place and a really tough race. All that said, the fact that three of our sport’s superstars took the challenge, to me, is awesome!
AJW
What do you mean American hopes dashed? Nikki ROCKED…what an achievement! As for the speedgoat boys, they rocked too! Can’t wait to hear the details.
I’m not sure that this result is very surprising. The Euros have been skiing, running and riding well in the high mountains since waaay back. It’s pretty arrogant to assume we could just waltz over there and beat everyone at their toughest race on their own turf (and on their own terms). I’m sure we won’t make that mistake again.
Here’s to next year!!!
Hi American friend, Ultratrail mont blanc is only for european affair!! With compliments for your partecipation,but Marco Olmo ( 59 year old) is great!
At first I was pretty happy so many good Americans were entering this race and was looking forward to a real show down. But I got a bit sick of reading how they were thinking of this race as if they could waltz in and take the record and it got really tiring and frankly it was that ‘ugly American’ thing all over again. If you haven’t guessed it, I am one of a bunch of Americans who live here in Chamonix.
So, I am glad to see the ‘GO USA’ type of arrogance finally was dashed against the rocks of the Alps. Come back again a little more humble boys, and maybe you will be able to make some type of a showing. Listen to the people around here, and do a little training on the course. Try to relate to the other athletes as ‘people’ and not just ‘Euros’ or ‘French’ or whatever you think of them as. Try to get a feel for what it’s all about before you start shooting your mouths off.
I didn’t hear any gossip in town about Nikki Kimball bragging before the race like I did about the USA boys. She just put her head down and did it. It’s typical American male arrogance to think that anything east of the Rockies can’t possibly be ‘hardcore’ and imagine that they’ll walk all over the race. Well, it spanked ‘em and spanked ‘em good. Eat a serving of humble pie.
You got beaten by a 59 year old Italian, a German in his 40s, and a Frenchman in his 40s (1,2 and 3). So there. I am tired of reading all the bloggy whining about ‘Ewww, it’s soo steep’ and ‘oh there are no switchbacks’. What do you friggin’ expect in the capital of extreme skiing and mountaineering, exactly? By the way – there ARE in fact switchbacks on many of the descents (but if you only run 1/2 the race I guess you don’t get to see all of them). And all that endless whining about how ‘we can’t have pacers’ and other crap because you have to be self sufficient and find it in yourself to run the whole race … Sheesh. And we all thought the French were just a bunch of garlic and cheese eating surrender monkeys, eh? Not quite.
At least Dean had the guts to finish the whole race this time (it’s his at least 3rd try I believe and he dropped out 2 other times), which is more than I can say for the others who dropped out when they realized they could not live up to their bragging. I thought that was very bad sportsmanship, actually, no matter how you slice or dice it. To find out people dropped out w/o a real race injury was a major disappointment to me as an American – I’d have rather felt I was from the ‘home of the brave’ and had many strong finishers, even further down the pack – rather than find we are represented by the ones who brag and then run away to hide when they realize they can’t live up to their bragging and don’t have the ego to say ‘yep, today I was beaten, I will come back and try again’.
And while you think that ‘ultramarathoning’ might be ‘new’ in Europe (it’s not actually), the sport of mountaineering was INVENTED here, as well as the profession of mountain guiding. Trying to go fast in the high mountains is something Europeans have been doing for a long time – they just usually didn’t wear running shoes to do it or call it a ‘race’. But setting records for faster and faster ascents of peaks around here is a major pasttime for the guiding community.
By the way, what a short shrift is being given to a fantastic athlete – Nikki Kimball BEAT EVERY OTHER AMERICAN IN THE RACE INCLUDING TOPHER GAYLORD AND DEAN KARNAZES (and of course the ones who dropped out). I am a bit tired of people looking only as ‘she won the woman’s race’ – she came in 19th SCRATCH and beat most boys (and ALL AMERICAN BOYS) ASSES to the ground! Go GIRL!
Bazzo, OLMO and the boys are incredible !
Thanks for the notes Samantha – It is great to here from an American in the Alps or where ever you are! Have you run Mt. Blanc yet?
Samantha hits this one right on the nail. The arrogance of the american guys did not go down well here, their behaviour on the start line was not worthy of top athletes and they need to take a more humble approach to this race. The vast majority of the participants are not out to make a time, it’s a MAJOR achievement to just complete the course in less than 46 hours. The whole fact about this race is purity, no prize money, a fantastic organisation and thousands of ordinary people cheering on every competitor from the first to the last, please come next time with a little more humility and try to enter into the spirit of this event. Congratulations to Nikki Kimball for a superb performance.
Scott and Karl are not arrogant. Whats wrong with being a ‘GO USA’ type as Samantha would say. I like to cheer for fellow Americans. Is there something wrong with that? We are no more arrogant than people from other countries cheering on their fellow country man. I think Samantha has some underlying issues that she needs to see a therapist about.
As sad as it was to see the top american men drop it was pretty cool to see a man that is almost 60 win this thing. My hat goes off to him. Gives me hope that I have a few good years left. And it was also cool to see Nikki Kimball to so well. She is an amazing athlete.
Samatha, WOW! What a lashing!! Did you actually hear any of the “top” Americans say they were going to trounce the “EUROS”? Or could it have possibly been the media hype? I have never heard Karl, Scott, nor Hal talk that way. They each approach every race to give it their best and some days it just isn’t there. Your comments go against everything that these guys stand for and Ultra running in AMERICA.
I’m sorry Samatha but you have a chip on your shoulders that is much, much deeper than just ultra running…
Let’s all give a shout out to the Cooper’s – Ryan and Lori! Ryan ran a very smart race finishing (correct me if I’m wrong) top American?? And Lori finishing in the top 10 for women!
Samantha,
I think you make some excellent points. I would like to point out that from my perspective the bragging was coming from the ultrarunning community, not the runners themselves. In every pre-race interview I saw or heard there was at most cautious optimism expressed by “the boys”. As this was not a target race for most, pulling out to save themselves for future efforts while perhaps not the height of bravery was a smart tactical move. Not the stuff of adventure novels but we’re each running our own race.
Hi WSG,
As mentioned, I do live in Chamonix. I have lived here for 6 years. I left the US when Bush took over, and basically have been pretty happy to be out of there every time I go back for a visit or turn on the world news.
My name is not Samantha, but I believe I have the right to choose a screen name for posting to blogs. It’s a small town here and my comments are not exactly ‘rah rah’ are they?
I am not any type of major athlete, nor do I pretend to be. I am ‘one of the many’ who enter races to say they’ve done them, with no hope of winning and basically to try to do a personal best. I do enjoy the outdoors and mountain sports. I ski and rock climb here and run trails a bit as well as hike, snow shoe and ski tour.
No, I have not run Mt. Blanc (4810m). Actually people climb it or ski it as it’s covered in ice and snow. In 1990, the Swiss Pierre-André Gobet, leaving from Chamonix, completed the ascent and descent in 5 hours, 10 minutes and 14 seconds (an amazing feat). No one normally comes close to that. Normally it’s a 20 hour day to climb the peak leaving from one of the higher huts.
I have however run a few trail races in the area and I have done the 86km North Face Courmayeur-Champex-Chamonix race last year and again this year (which we English speaking locals now refer to as the ‘Fun Run’).
This race happens the same weekend as the UTMB and takes off at noon on Friday from Courmayeur and it has a 24 hour time limit and 4500m of uphill/downhill (14,764 ft). We generally finish in time to take a shower, have a nap, and see the first guys come over the finish for the UTMB that afternoon. Finishers of the big race continue to come in all through the night and into the following day. I have friends who do the big race as well, though most of my friends do the smaller one.
For the Fun Run, I train using chunks of the entire Tour du Mont Blanc hiking trail as my long runs, up to 42km at a time. It’s also a popular hiking trail where we take friends and family who visit, as well as hiking clients. So I am familiar with the whole UTMB course.
Today they interviewed on the radio the last place finisher (a French woman) who was on the course for the full allotted 46 hours. They treated her like a hero as well because she had the guts to stick it out. This course is very much about finishing it, not only winning it.
I sat at the dinner last night – the closing dinner for the two races – with several other runners from the US and UK.
I saw the winner Marco Olmo at a table with his family, eating and occaisionally being congratulated by one or two people (but not mobbed – very low key). I also saw Dawa Sherpa sitting with his family, and as he passed by our table and wished us ‘bon appetite’. Many of the top finishers were there at the dinner, as well as many of the ‘just managed to finish’ finishers were there. I didn’t notice any of the top American runners but it was a big room – I could have missed them.
There were no speeches or grandstanding – just a film showing some bits of the race on a screen above us including shots of the first four UTMB finishers coming over the line in Chamonix.
But mainly it was just a bunch of people talking together about the races they’d done (CCC or UTMB or other various race experiences), how many blisters they had, what injuries they sustained, what were their favorite or most hated bits of the race, and what kinds of food they could or could not stomach during the race – all while drinking some good wine and eating some great food provided by the race organizers.
Both of these races are an excellent trail running experience if you are open to having it. I highly recommend doing either race, and either arriving a week early or staying in town a bit after as well to get to see the full beauty of these mountains in the daylight.
Pre-race, at the handing out of race numbers, Scott and a few others were overheard talking about how they would try to break the course record. He mentioned on his blog about his ‘lowest ever starting number’ for an ultra marathon (as if he was not being given his due). And then yes, this blog talking about USA vs Europeans and all the comments as the race was followed live made me ill to read, I have to say. I am sorry – but who has the chip on their shoulder here? Who made this a USA vs. Europeans race to start with? It was not me.
Samantha says:
“Pre-race, at the handing out of race numbers, Scott and a few others were overheard talking about how they would try to break the course record.”
Why wouldn’t that be their goal? You can respect the course and what it demands and still aspire to breaking the course record.
Samantha says:
“He mentioned on his blog about his ‘lowest ever starting number’ for an ultra marathon (as if he was not being given his due).”
Actually it was the highest number he’d ever received in an ultra. You read it that he was claiming he was not getting his due; I read it that he’d never been in an ultra with enough participants to print starting numbers into the thousands.
Brennen
Thanks for your comments Samantha,
as a German ultrarunner now living in the Rockies
I am not used to the pacing part in the 100 Mile races.
In Europe this would be considered cheating, since only racers with a starting number can pace others.
In Leadville I figured out myself that running without an pace or a big crew makes a big time difference at the finishline.
Maybe this was the part the US boys were not used to.
I met Karl and Scott and they seemed not arrogant at all.
But I think Karl mentioned the 16h mark could be smashed.
So I think Karl thought they can pull that off ( And I thought that as well)
I didn’t know Marc Olmo, but I know Jens Lukas and he is one of the best 24h racers in the world and by far the best German runner for a good decade.
But thats Ultrarunning: You have to make it to the finish line first.
And its allways a long way to go.
All have a good week
Markus
Samanta you have worked yourself into a frenzy over nothing. Scott didn’t say anything arrogant in his blog you just misinterpreted what he said. You are looking for controversy where none exist. And what exactly did Karl and Hal or the other american men do that was arrogant?
The post race dinner sounds like ones I have been to over here in the states. I’ve never been to a post race dinner that was not low key. However many of us americans are not sophisticated enough to say ‘bon appetite’, you have me there. Treating the last place person as a hero is not unique to Europe. Every race I’ve been in the last place person was treated as a hero for gutting it out. I have not witnessed any grandstanding at races either. Guess I’m not sure why you even brought this stuff up.
Quite a cross section of posters. Different nationalities, elite and not-elite runners, college runners and not-college runners, hillbillies and not-hillbillies, Elvis, and apparently the rich and not so rich. All runners though and that’s pretty cool.
you gotta love free speech!!
Fast Eddy – Correction. As stated in my comment earlier – Nikki Kimball was the first American to cross the finish line.
Not only did she cross as the first woman, but also as the first American. She is the American hero of the race if you want to make it into that sort of a thing.
Interesting to me that she is a girl and her name was overlooked in your search for ‘first American finisher’ even though I mentioned it earlier, and so far no other guy here has bothered to correct you on your mistake. But then what would American guys care about defending a girl who beat the pants off of them anyhow?
Yes, I am sure I did misread Scott’s blog (re: the race number thing). Point taken.
Simply please go and re-read the first paragraph of this blog post that we are all commenting on – and you should see exactly what I mean by arrogance or attitude issues.
We have here one of the top USA runner’s friends calling ‘everyone else’ outside of Americans in the race “Crafty Europeans” and framing the race as US vs Europe and as well mentioning how they (Americans) are there to ‘steal the show’?
So just where exactly does that xenophobic term about “crafty europeans” come from? And what’s’ with framing the race as USA vs. Europe like we have nationally sponsored ultra running teams or something? (Europe not even being a nation but whatever).
Americans have raced in this race (and even placed well) since the first year it was held (Topher Gaylord being 2nd in the 2003 race, and an American woman winning as the first woman in 2003) and there should have been plenty of people who spoke English to ask what the course was like if anyone bothered to look or have a Google at past events and wanted to get some ‘local knowledge’. It is also a race held on one of the most highly travelled walking paths in Europe. There are detailed guide books (in English) to the whole trail (which is usually done in 7-10 days).
Jeff I think you miss my point, which is that what the top Americans did by bragging as they came over that they would set a new course record was not horrible in and of itself – if they could do it, great and more power to them of course. I was directly challenged about anyone from the US bragging and being arrogant (as if nothing had been said that could possibly be misconstrued as boastful). So I mentioned it.
Now that I do mention someone talking in public about how they will break the record, I am told it was not bragging but a ‘personal goal’. Well come on. Get real. Of course it’s a brag. Having a personal goal is well – personal. Piping on about it for all the world to hear is another thing generally called boasting. Even if you are good.
When you are new in town and have never run the course before, and then brag about how great you are in a public place for others to overhear — and then don’t finish and are not injured? Well of course you might have a few people posting blog comments about it. You set yourself up for it! Don’t act all innocent and surprised about that – you’d make the same critique thing if French guys came to the Western states and were picking up their race numbers and getting together and talking about walking all over the record there like it was nothing — and then dropped out half way around too because their legs were not ‘100%’.
It simply looked like they were too egotistical to be seen getting beaten after the earlier statements about record breaking. That’s what it looks like from over here especially after the blog posts we read – and especially as all 3 ‘top American men’ all did the same thing.
Then add to that the online blog whining about the course being hard and how you could not have pacers, and how it was all dark and steep and that their might be ‘unwritten rules’ or double standards – well it just sounds whiny and like excuse making.
Jeff – I pointed out the way that the French view the last place finishers, and what the dinner was like (and the potential absence of the top US runners at said dinner) to make a point that really they are not ‘crafty Europeans’ and that there is no ‘media frenzy’ here as some have stated – not that it was ‘so sophisticated’ or cloyingly sweet – but that it was JUST LIKE EVERY OTHER RACE you’ve been to and is not the way some blog about it like it’s some Martian culture that is so different from your own.
And by the way – Dawa Sherpa said ‘bon appetite’ because he speaks French as his main 2nd language, and frankly because that’s just a common courtesy phrase here – my point was that he was outgoing and friendly – not that he’s trying to be sophisticated. French just happens to be the language we speak here in France, you know. Go have your ‘freedom fries’ somewhere else with that side order of humble pie.
Here – before the race the small French ultra running sports press printed an article which looked at Scott and Karl with respect as very good trail runners who were coming here, and who were actually favored to win the UTMB race and their previous long list of wins were mentioned with nothing but admiration in the article.
Maybe some of you need some therapy yourselves to understand why you need to cling to the stars and stripes so tightly instead of using your own personal self-confidence when either watching or running races in Europe.
Screen name “Samatha” this is screen name “Fast Eddy”
Did I read somewhere in your doctoral thesis about living in France because of Bush?? Naw – you don’t have a chip on your shoulder at all, do you??
You do realize we are talking about running here, don’t you?? Just plain ‘ol simple running…..
Pingback: American men schooled at the Ultra Tour du Mont-Blanc | Trail Running Blog
On Scott’s blog he suggests that the top runners had pacers and were cheating. In the case of Nicholas Mermould could someone explain how he was paced if he was in the lead on his own for 133km before finally finishing third?
I feel it might be better that he admits that he underestimated the course and the quality of the European runners. We’ll see what happens next year.
Wow…you are all spending too much time writing and bagging all of this UTMB stuff. Just mellow out and sign up for the race in 2008 and come over to Chamonix and do it. It is a great experience. You will see for yourself maybe why they stopped. It is a tough trail and just to finish is a proud result wether you are in the top 10 or the last to finish!
Okay maybe the “boys” under estimated the difficulty of the trail and also the level of competetion.
I think they will be back for revenge to redeem themselves to the course and the “euros”. If they do come back I am sure they will not be at Hardrock just before.
It was too bad they stopped because the event needs a new winner not a 59 yr old italian. (again) Yes, 59…crazy!
Also you might not understand the difficulties in running a 100 miler in a foreign counrty. Not only do you have the challenge of the course but you have to battle jet lag, diet change, language and culture differnces. Not easy. And this race starts at 6:30 pm with 2,700 people and runs into towns with 10,000 people cheering you on like the tour de france. It is a whole new level to ultras. Nothing like a 100 miler in the US. It is so much fun and full of continuous energy.
Come expereeince it yourself!
Top American Finisher of the 86km
Ok Samantha, you are now the most popular writer at our website, thank you for the publicity. I will be brief now and will write a real post later, but here is our rundown. (1) Scott and I never made this a Euro vs. American race, that was the ultrarunning community itself. (2) When we mentioned the course record, let’s remember that this is a different course than previous years meaning the winner is the course record holder. (3) I felt pretty good coming over there and felt I had a chance to win, however, my quads pretty much seized at 123km and I made a strong effort to still finish but decided I did not want to walk for 12 hours over 18 miles, it just was not worth my time. It was my 5th 100 mile race in 4 1/2 months, I have proved in the past this has not affected me, this time it may have, who knows? But now excuses on that, I gave it what I had. (4) and lastly for now, not many people may know this but we sat down with the race directors the day before and discussed the rules so we would not do anything to jeopardize us being disqualified, that being said, the race starts and as I was running in the front of the race most of the day, I was slightly frustrated seeing many switchbacks being cut when the race was clearly marked to go a different way, I saw the winner have a pacer in two places, I saw a number of times a few of the leaders accept aid OUTSIDE of the aid station. If you go to the rules about the race, ALL three of these rules I listed were broken all day long by French, German, Italian lead runners and it was lame to see that.. Perhaps this is why drug testing exists so much in Europe and other countries outside of Europe…its cheating! Here in the USA we dont cheat. Oh, yah, as far as pacers, I dont use them so I am moot on that one. I dont think pacers should be allowed in any races, I agree with Europe on that one. And Samantha, relax, I got to run all day long in the Alps, who can complain about that. 0 scrapes for cheating, 10 scrapes for and awesome course. Wahsatchspeedgoat
Samantha says:
“Now that I do mention someone talking in public about how they will break the record, I am told it was not bragging but a ‘personal goal’. Well come on. Get real. Of course it’s a brag. Having a personal goal is well – personal. Piping on about it for all the world to hear is another thing generally called boasting. Even if you are good.”
You originally said the Americans were talking about how they were going to *try* to break the record. Your claim here is something else entirely, as now you’re saying you heard they proclaimed they *would* break it. Which is it? Because my response to the latter would be very different.
I don’t agree with you on the boasting part. Simply put: Can you really boast or brag about something before you’ve even done it?
Look, I’m not flying my flag here. And I respect you for sticking to your guns. Just keep your story straight.
Brennen
I just wanted to point out what an arrogant ass Scott Jurek is:
from scottjurek.com….
“what a fantastic experience! I would highly recommend this event for the course is fantastic with its beauty and ruggedness. The support and volunteers along the way are outstanding. The French and other European runners are incredibly strong and talented. And I’m sure anyone who’s run one of our low key ultras in the States would get an extreme thrill out of standing at a starting line with over 2,000 other runners in Chamonix, running through the streets lined with thousands of cheering spectators, into aid stations and through towns with the same. It’s like the Tour de France, a large party out there, literally! It’s an incredible production. The race organizers put on an amazing event! Tons of fun! I hope to come back fresh to experience the rest of the course. And the finish line which runs through the town of Chamonix lined with supporters and people in cafes and restaurants watching through the day and night. ”
I have the utmost respect for Scott and Karl as athletes (as well as everyone else who signed up for UTMB, but since we’re on the topic…), which involves them understanding their underlying motivation behind why they run… and I’m quite certain it is something common to anyone who runs in the mountains. In my interaction and observation of them both they are true ambassadors to the sport, respecting all who show up at the starting line of a beautiful race.
The trail-running community is small and tight-knit in the U.S.A. and hence the rooting for anyone on the “home team”. Many folks (myself included) from the States don’t know (or didn’t know) the names of the top athletes at UTMB this year, but that certainly doesn’t mean that we do not hold them in the highest regard. If anything, for me it was really exciting to read about a whole bunch of bad-asses that I’ve never heard of before. One really exciting aspect of the ultras that I’ve done in the States is that they are starting to have a larger international presence, and what a neat context to meet people from all over the world. I think that a love for the outdoors is universal and knows no gender or national boundaries. I think trail running can and should be one of the many small things in life that can bring people together, not create division. I don’t believe that anyone reading/posting on this blog has any negative objectives. If it is animosity that fuels you, I suggest looking elsewhere as there are there are far more vicious activities than trail running….
Right on! to all who laced up for what looks like an incredible race, I hope to have the opportunity to do it someday.
Another bit of despicable national competitiveness…
Quoting Scott, “Congrats to my Brazilian friend Valmir Nunes on his record setting win at Badwater. We met in the 2006 Spartathlon and I saw him the day before this year’s Badwater and we exchanged jerseys and autographs. And challenges. I told him, with much respect, that if he breaks my record, I’ll go to Brazil and break his. I think we’ll be competing head to head again soon (Spartathlon 2007???). Looking forward to the challenge of again racing with this great man.:”
No matter the outcome, I rooted for my Team. What excitement! Thanks for towing the line and giving it your best! Oh, and Colleen is my real name…
Well Karl,
I have been reading these postings for a while, keeping silent. But now that you start accusing people-including me- for things that are not true, I do not shut my mouth any longer.
You say:”ALL three of these rules I listed were broken all day long by French, German, Italian lead runners and it …..”
I was crew to Jens Lukas from Germany, the 2nd in the race in the end. The next German to reach the finish was no “lead runner”, 56th, so you actually are accusing Jens and me of cheating!
The biggest worry I usually have in crewing, is, that I could by mistake do something, that is against the rules and could lead to the disqualification of Jens! I read the rules very carefully and additionally asked at every aid-station, where I was allowed to be and to assist Jens! Actually at most aid stations the crews were not allowed in the area, where food and drinks were provided for the runners, but before or behind that area, sometimes more or less “outside”.
Jens has had no pacer, he runs HIS pace in all his races. I was the only crew to him aided a little by the photographers team of a sponsor (these mostly took care of my dog, while I was busy with Jens, and sometimes one of them assisted me)
For as to cutting the switchbacks, Jens himself will also speak up to this. I know that there are people cutting short the switch-backs. We discussed about the issue already last year, the conclusion was: stick to the marked trail, it is a matter of honesty and also an environmental matter.
By the way, you have been running far in front of Jens all the time until shortly before Bovine: Champex Lac Meltzer: 15:56h Lukas: 16:46h;
Bovine Lukas 18:17h, Meltzer 18:20. So you probably have seen Jens only once in the race (exception the start) for a very short time shortly before Bovine! I have not even been near to the aid station of Bovine since I was driving straight from Champex Lac to Trient).
So I really wonder, what you claim to have seen, regarding Jens and regarding me crewing??
So, think about what you have written. If you stick to saying, Jens and I, crewing him, were cheating, then I am saying you are a liar!
And if you have been only saying this thing out into the blue because you have seen someone cheating in the front positions not knowing who he was and from what country, but must have been one ore other European, so lets include German as well, than I must say it is a really ugly thing to write such an accusation, that indicates no person directly, but indirectly drags a honest person’s name in the mud! Sure noone can sue you, you did not speak a name, you just spoke out in general. But I had not been looking in here yet today and we came to know about your saying by the worried question of a German runner. So you make that people with a good reputation have to defense themselves for things they have not done. And I wonder who else of the lead runners would feel the same about it, if he knew?
This speculation about European honesty in general is so ridicoulous, I do not comment further on it.
I am sorry, I do not know you and I try to not have any preoccupation about anybody before I know him. But this “blindly” lashing about is neither fair nor does it make you look a good sport.
I really would like you to clear that. Be fair!
To the rest of the people writing/reading here:
Looking from Europe it was funny to see this making up of a concurrence between USA and the Europeans, especially, since many of the people doing so, seemed not to know much about the European runners (e.c. Marco was winner of the UTMB last year and has a history of first places in mountain trail races, did they expect that you usually win just like nothing over here??).
From the runners’ side I fortunately do/did not see anything of this (up to now and here): At the Spartathlon e.g., it is quite usual that I also help runners without crew in the aidstations, that are arriving before Jens. Perhaps you think how dumb one can be to help the “concurrence”, but I do and Jens fully approves of that, because the runners there feel more like a big family also if they are running “versus” each other. From the Americans we only know Scott. None would have begrudged him his Spartathlon victory last year. Jens is francly saying, that he would not have been able to catch up to him there last year, even if he had not dropped out due to injury. Jens tried to make Scott go on in Courmayeur now. After Scott dropped out Scott and Leah kept following the course and we found them to be friendly as usual at all stations and cheering for Jens (and why should it have been different???).
We met Leah on the way to the closing dinner. She obviously did not know about it and invited us to join the Americans’ group going out for dinner. We are looking foreward to meeting again in Athens in a few weeks (if the fires there hopefully get stopped and the race takes place).
At the ceremony the cheering for the first (Marco, an Italian) was much, much louder than for everybody else. This in France, where people are said to be very patriotic, and in a race where a Frenchman was 3rd and where mainly French people attended! The spectators were fair enough, it was amazing how much they appreciated achievement over nationality!!
This is what I like about our sport (in contrast to team sports like sokker etc), that it brings us together. And I am sad to see, if people try to use it to build up walls!
Keep on running
Maya
Maya, No I did not see Jens all day, except when he blazed by me and asked how I am. He was a gentleman. As far as you saying me using German, again I can not tell nationalities by just looking and I should have left German out of it, I can say I only saw the crewing, cutting from the other two. 1st and 3rd, appologies to Jens on that, I know from Scott that Jens is a nice guy and a super competitor, and certainly one of the best ever. Perhaps I should have used “a few other runners”. I don’t like to be the bad guy here, I would have kept all this shit to myself and maybe a few local friends had it not been started from someone posting something here to start the big fight, I think we should all get over it and go for a run and forget it. Leave the battle back on the trail, next time if we get to race there we can all have fun running through the Alps.
You sound like my wife, a super crew that help others in need, but always legally. Guten Tag
WOW The end!
Pingback: Jessie
Pingback: ben kingsley filmography
W0t9yz gstyrbcpwbvb, [url=http://wsbiisrevstm.com/]wsbiisrevstm[/url], [link=http://iwxoptvbiwsy.com/]iwxoptvbiwsy[/link], http://jwbapxczqqrw.com/
I am really thankful to this topic because it really gives great information :.*